Editor’s Note: Cathy Truong is a Vietnamese American who spent two years living in Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi. She submitted this story on LGBT rights issues to Tuoi Tre News from Vancouver, Canada, where she now lives. There has been lots of media attention in the past few years regarding LGBT rights issues that have come to the forefront such as the possibility of legalization of same-sex marriage in Vietnam. The Southeast Asian country will soon host its second annual LGBT pride event. In November 2013, a Marriage and Family Law article, which prohibits same-sex marriage, was struck down. This was a huge stride for Vietnam. But one researcher and activist, Dr. Natalie Newton, has been asking, “How does the ‘L’ fare in the Vietnamese LGBT movement?” Newton, a Vietnamese-American LGBT activist now based in Los Angeles, California, spent 21 months in Vietnam (2009-2010 and summers of 2006, 2007, and 2008), conducting ethnographic research on the social politics of Ho Chi Minh City’s lesbian community. Her dissertation, ‘A Queer Political Economy of Community,’ was funded by the Fulbright-Hays award, which is a partnership between the Vietnamese government and the U.S. Department of Education. What many LGBT human rights activists and critical scholars call the “Pink Dollar” or “Rainbow Dollar” is a stream of funding from intergovernmental organizations (IGOs) that entail serious contingencies in the way that LGBT rights are manifested locally, especially in developing countries. Newton asserts that the recent media buzz around Vietnam’s seemingly liberalized stance on LGBT rights and recent flow of hundreds of thousands of dollars in IGO funding for LGBT human rights projects is inevitably linked to improving Vietnam’s economic position by proxy. Vietnam’s sudden attention as a trail-blazer in Asia around same-sex marriage facilitates international business and geopolitical investment in the country that recently joined the WTO in 2007. IGOs and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) have supported Vietnam’s gay community and men who have sex with men (MSM) for decades since the HIV/AIDS pandemic hit Vietnam in the late 1980s. However, only a few studies have focused on Vietnamese female homosexuality. The Vietnamese NGO and think-tank Institute for Studies of Society, Economy, and Environment (iSEE) released a study on 40 lesbians in 2011. However, unlike studies on male homosexuality, these few studies on women have led to little or no lesbian-specific programming in Vietnam. Newton states that even when NGOs do reach out to women, they encounter much difficulty with access. And there is a significant theoretical gap between the longer-standing Vietnamese feminist movement, which has often advocated for women in terms of heterosexual rape, heterosexual domestic violence, human trafficking, or incest, and truly feminist studies on lesbians, who have encountered abuse, corrective rape of lesbians, sex workers who practice uncommon sexual activities, or women who identify as sexually fluid. The Vietnamese NGO Center for Studies and Applied Sciences in Gender, Family, Women, and Adolescents released a general handbook on lesbianism that featured one woman whose parents drugged her. The testimony reported that the woman’s parents invited a male family friend to have sex with their child to reverse their child’s sexual orientation while she was unconscious. Corrective rape is a complex feminist issue that bridges Vietnamese women’s advocacy with lesbian rights in particular. However there has yet to be significant programming or visibility around these issues in Vietnam. Newton states that Vietnamese lesbian communities are hard to reach due to factors including lack of real partnership between the lesbian community and NGOs who seek to conduct more studies or programming. Despite the lack of IGO and NGO involvement, the lesbians in Ho Chi Minh City have formed a close-knit community, organizing large-scale events through many transnational and online-based groups that host events offline. Cross-country charity events, sports championships, and butch beauty pageants were but a few during the time Newton conducted her research. While legalizing same-sex marriage is progressive, it will not necessarily improve how lesbians are viewed, nor will it diminish the daily struggle for many gays and lesbians whose lives are much more than just marriage to their partners. According to Newton, discrimination is much broader than the institution of marriage. Some of Newton’s lesbian informants acknowledge that same-sex marriage will not change their lives. Education and awareness of LGBT issues is more important. When people in Vietnam understand and accept lesbian women and the struggles they face, the women will feel more accepted by society. Before same-sex marriage legalization takes place, Vietnam must address the attitudes and beliefs of the general public towards lesbians and the LGBT community.
More
3 major gateway hospitals in Ho Chi Minh City set to open this year
The hospitals include Thu Duc Regional General Hospital, Hoc Mon Regional General Hospital, and Cu Chi Regional General Hospital
Read more
Dengue fever, encephalitis multiply throughout Vietnam
Vietnam is about to hit the height of the dengue fever season, while encephalitis is also reaching epidemic proportions in many regions of the Southeast Asian country
7 years agoVietnam to concentrate on streamlining political system during important Party meeting
Reforming the country’s political system is a top priority on the meeting agenda
7 years agoJealous Vietnamese husband stabs wife to death in front of child
A man in northern Vietnam brutally killed his wife by stabbing her 18 times out of jealousy while the couple were in the hospital to care for their sick child.
7 years agoHighlights
Int’l tourists flock to Vietnam’s Phu Quoc for Vietnamese Tet celebrations
Restaurants, entertainment venues, and tourist attractions on the island have been bustling with visitors
Latest news
Int’l tourists flock to Vietnam’s Phu Quoc for Vietnamese Tet celebrations
Restaurants, entertainment venues, and tourist attractions on the island have been bustling with visitors
Ho Chi Minh City pagodas thronged with visitors on Tet holiday
Many worshippers dressed in ao dai, carrying incense, flowers, and offerings to present at the altar
Japan sinkhole grows to almost Olympic pool length
The cavity has expanded to 40 meters (130 feet) across
Drizzle, cold weather expected in northern Vietnam this weekend
Nighttime temperatures could drop to 12-15 degrees Celsius
7 die as car plunges into river in Vietnam’s Nam Dinh
Two others survived the fatal accident
Neymar announces return to Brazil's Santos
He played just seven times for Al Hilal despite a reported salary of around $104 million a year
French luxury billionaire sparks tax debate with threat to leave
He suggested that companies could flee France for the U.S. to escape a planned tax hike
Investigators recover plane black boxes from Washington air collision
The mid-air collision killed 67 people
Driver faces $1,600 fine for wrong-way driving on northern Vietnam expressway
She explained that she was unfamiliar with the road and mistakenly drove against traffic
Traffic accident deaths in Vietnam decline over Tet’s first 6 days
This improvement coincides with the enforcement of Government Decree 168, which came into effect early this year